In 1994, 13-year old Nicholas Barclay disappeared from his parental home in Texas. For three years there was no sign of life of Nicholas. And then, in 1997, his family received a call from Spain. Authorities said they had found a boy who claimed he was Nicholas. His sister Carey traveled to Spain and brought her brother back home. But something seems to be off with this story, it seems too good to be true... Director Bart Layton examines the strange affair and gradually unravels the shocking truth.